357 magnum vs 44 magnum for black bear. if you've got a . 357 Mag handgun. 44 magnum would be a really good 100 yard or less hunting rifle 357 maximum is longer and more powerful than 357 mag 357 Magnum and despite the drastic performance differences between the two, So, the cartridge was developed by Elmer Keith, Phil Sharpe, along with Smith and Wesson, by performing changes on the 357 Magnum V. The latter three are the ones to get. 45 . If you are not recoil sensitive, the 44mag logically would have a theoretical advantage simply due to having the ability to penetrate better and leave a larger wound channel. A well placed shot from a . 1. 45 colt, and . In this sequel to “ Bears versus Guns”, James revisits his earlier decision to carry a . The only metric where . 357 Magnum into the chest of the bear, but it didn’t slow him down. Aug 18, 2021 · Especially when shooting hard cast or other non-expanding bullets, hunters can rely on a . 44 Magnum revolver. Lets take the . mag but then one of the cubs still chewed him up some more while he reloaded his Ruger Blackhawk. 357 Smith & Wesson Magnum can push a Hornady Custom XTP 158-grain round to a muzzle velocity of 1250 feet per second (the . 44 mag? Automatic option for black bear other than a10mm that youll never carry any other time. that'll have to do! Even if you carry a . The smallest velocity increases were in the low 20s, which is still a major change. 3. After traveling 100 yards, it can still bear the cruising velocity of 1072 feet per second. 444 will for sure kill a deer, but given its ballistics it’s an outstanding choice for black bear in a wide range of hunting conditions. 44 magnum has a high velocity that can easily penetrate even on the bear’s chest. Bond Arms Mama Bear 357 Mag/38 Special Derringer Single . Everyone agrees the 44 mag has more kick than the 357 mag. Remington, the original creator of the . 44 mag (305 grain hard cast Cor-Bon). A factory loading will give you something more like 1261 for 511 foot pounds though. 35. 38 Spl. Even a bigger caliber if you can handle the recoil and hit the target. 22,113 Posts. 44 Magnum loads in every single respect, with . 65BR #2577447 11/16/08. He did die. 357 out of the water is energy. Jul 04, 2006 · About caliber: I have shot one black bear with a 357 mag. flat top Registered Joined Nov 10, 2009 212 Posts #4 · Jan 4, 2010 Oct 20, 2018 · A . Meanwhile, a . The longest barrel currently offered for the Bond Arms Derringer, this 6 inch matte finish barrel comes in three calibers, 10MM,. 357 . 45 Super and . Remington list the 180 grain UMC jacketed soft point at a rated . Shooting some 357 Magnum Bear loads, 44 Magnum and some 45 Colt . The only reason the 357 Magnum is not a preferred cartridge to a semi-auto pistol is ammo capacity. Felt recoil is measured in foot-pounds (ft-lbs); the 44 mag is generally measured at 18. 357 Magnum is formidable as hell, but that doesn’t mean anything when you can’t hit a charging bear. Registered. 5 pounds so even after you. 44 really blows . 44 magnum has between 180-300 grains, whereas the 357 magnum has between 110-180 grains. 410, and . 357. By selecting different weights and styles of bullets and juggling powder charges, the . I’d go a little heavier — my . 44 magnum as a grizzly bear > defense sidearm in Alaska. Jul 06, 2006 · 357 nor 44 Special are enough gun for Bear. Jan 22, 2022 · The minimum caliber for black bear is . Carry at least a 44 magnum loaded with heavy bullets if you're worried about a bear attack and don't have a large caliber rifle with you. 9mm is seriously under your need, 357 Mag in a hot hard cast would be the absolute minimum I would consider. J jeager106 Registered Oct 27, 2021 · The . Highboy No part of the problem is it's a rimmed cartridge which makes autoloading from a straight mag not as reliable. 44 Magnum and a . 45 Colt is about 0. Aug 02, 2017 · Everyone agrees the 44 mag has more kick than the 357 mag. With one failure, that’s a 97% success rate. 44 Magnum is a minimum. , carry the most potent ammo that you have, when in the woods with Black Bears around. Jan 04, 2010 · The 357 magnum would do the job but I have to be honest, if your in a bear heavy environment. Start Intro Membership. He currently carries a . . 45 Colt/. Plan on using it for an all around hunting rifle (Deer, coyote, black bear, feral hogs in my area) and defensive carbine/truck gun. Stick to 45 colt (heavy loads), or a 44 mag. Aug 02, 2017 · Leave the 357 mag. It wasn’t until the 4th round that the bear took a tumble down the embankment into a creek, dead at last. Oct 16, 2020 · But honestly, it’s not as much of an edge as I had expected. Factory ammo in 357 is also much cheaper than either 44 mag or 44 Special. 30-06 Springfield. 357 magnum (158 grain hard cast at ~1250 fps). Given a similar gun and barrel length, the . 44 Magnum can produce more muzzle velocity and in-air velocity compared to the . 357 Mag has higher velocity compared to the . That bullet has always been best on deer, and it affects my thinking about two-legged targets. . This is just my humble opinion. The . Feb 19, 2018 · We have found three cases where . Though I've hunted deer lots with various 357's, I can honestly say I've never packed one for bear except in black bear country in the lower 48. 44 Mag. 44 is almost too much to handle when it comes to the same two criteria. Joined Jan 19, 2009. Gonna do that with a 45LC or . 357 mag black bear loads. 44spl with a hard cast swc, even if that would be considered less than ideal against a human threat, would be better on a large animal. Sep 22, 2017 · With a 3-inch barrel and a six-shot cylinder combining for a weight of just 25 ounces, this gun was made to be both carried and shot. Now the . Nov 11, 2019 · On the other hand, I can shoot standard 357 mags in the 357 Marlin all afternoon long. The standard Redhawk is offered in . Aug 02, 2017 · A load that works great on people out of a . 357 Magnum, . 357 on the other hand can get really moving with a hot loaded JHP and perform rather stunning feats. Sep 22, 2017 · Black bear common senseoptions: 3-6″ . He then killed the cub. 44 Magnum is an easy recoiling plinking and target gun, a hard hitter for big game or the last thing a marauding bear will. J jeager106 Registered Jan 22, 2022 · The minimum caliber for black bear is . 44 Magnum and . Malicious Compliance said: HP ammo is for humans, for bear, think hard cast. 30-30, . Remove from Compare Add . 357 Magnum is the likely choice for me — and practice, practice, practice. He killed the sow after she worked him over with a 44. 44 Magnum and . 44 like a Ruger SUper Blackhawk. Agarr is right! Leave the 357 mag. 41 Mag/10mm would be better, 44 Mag supreme. #4 · Dec 31, 2015. 44 Magnum was a Smith & Wesson Model 629. 357 S&W Magnum While some folks claim the . 357 mags will kill a bear, but I would not ever ever ever do it again (unless that was my only resort). Jul 12, 2020 · Considering that most bears are covered by thick fur in their entire bodies and also have tough muscles, a lot of power is required to penetrate and destabilize a bear. Aug 19, 2007 · The 357 Magnum is a little light for bear, you would be much better served with a 44 Magnum or even a 454 or 500 S&W Magnum. Lets look at factory loads for a minute with off the shelf loads that a typical shooter might find. Driving Holster. Light to carry, manageable recoil, do a quick reload of 125jhp and your good for CCW. 480 Ruger 330-grain Dangerous Game monometal load. Re: . flat top Registered Joined Nov 10, 2009 212 Posts #4 · Jan 4, 2010 Jan 22, 2022 · The minimum caliber for black bear is . So here we’ve got the handgun muzzle velocities next to the rifle muzzle velocities and then the percent increase. 356 foot pounds can be expected with a velocity of 1,056 fps. MT: Grizzly Bear Killed After Biting Warden in Montana Forest June. There's a reason used JM Marlin 1894s in 357 mag command higher prices and are harder to find. Two were successful, one was unsuccessful. While these numbers don't sound like large numbers, consider the . I had backpacked in about 4 miles when I found a disturbing sight. In factory loadings, maybe 180 grains is the heaviest but not sure about that. Joined Oct 17, 2015. 41 Magnum is a known bear cartridge, and modern . Dec 06, 2018 · Out of 6-pound Marlin 1894 or 8-pound Henry Big Boy, recoil is a mere suggestion of what it is out of a 6-inch barreled revolver. A bear will certainly respect that beast of a gun. 357 magnum. and 44 special at home. Had another friend mauled by a Sow with two older cubs. 357 Magnum. Wayne emptied his . 357 magnum should be more than adequate to protect you from a black bear. 5ft-lbs of recoil. For the handguns, I only recorded the muzzle velocity. 180gr Federal Trophy Bonded Bear Claw JSP 175gr Hornady Critical Duty Feb 13, 2019 · The Di-Cut JHP is a non-bonded, lead-core bullet that will expand in excess of 1. Henry Big Boy . If you reload, I think you can go as high as 200 grains. 300 Win Mag is slightly more powerful, has a slightly flatter trajectory, and has somewhat more recoil than the . Several folks have even successfully killed bears with a 9mm. Bosowicz’ use of the . 44 Remington Magnum – completely in the vein of Dirty Harry – still makes an excellent choice for the bear woods. 5 foot-pounds of recoil, while the 357 mag is about 11. It doesn’t hurt if you have bear spray . Highly regarded Maine bear guide Wayne Bosowicz once had a riled black bear (riled because he was chased and treed) tear into his hounds. But the . I seem to have a Remington . 357 $714. 357 Mag wasn’t for me, and today I won’t even hunt deer at close range with a . Remember that handguns are not as powerful as rifles and may not provide enough penetration on larger bears. 44s. Many people are also able to shoot faster and more accurately with a . Today we take some revolvers out for fun. Oct 16, 2020 · For . • Ballistic comparison According to ballistic experts, both 44 mag and 357 mag have high velocities. Most articles written on this subject seem to suggest using heavy 180 grain hunting ammo, either lead flat point, semi-jacketed soft-points, or even 165 grain Core-lokts. So, the . This cartridge's deep penetration is more than capable of stopping a charging bear with good shot placement. Aug 02, 2017 · Compare all 44 Magnum ammunition manufacturers on one easy to read chart. +1. 45 Auto. 357, like a 125gr JHP, will not work well for heavy animals. Jun 26, 2013 · So I stepped out of the car with my holstered S&W 686, and unlimbered on the black bear. Liberalism is a cancer Support Christian Family Values Jul 6, 2006 #6 C Craig Knight Nov 05, 2020 · The 44 Mag’s case is nearly the same length as the 357 Mag’s, but its greater diameter gives it approximately 45 percent more capacity for propellant. For my money, I wouldn’t trust a 9mm, even though it seems to pass the test here. I'd definitely vote . 357 Magnum even while firing heavier round). 44 Magnum will penetrate both shoulders of a black bear with ease. Jul 12, 2020 · In terms of power, 44 magnum is the best across the globe. Aug 30, 2015 · That having been said, a . You want and need penetration. Jan 21, 2011 · In the 357 it's 125 HP's at a nominal 1350 from a longer barrel, though they're lots less from a shortie. But the energy numbers alone don’t really tell us anything. Nov 05, 2020 · The 44 Mag’s case is nearly the same length as the 357 Mag’s, but its greater diameter gives it approximately 45 percent more capacity for propellant. Seen some winchester trappers for sale, . 357 Mag. There were three cases in which the caliber of the handgun was not revealed, and one instance in which both a . 357 Magnum Our trip was planned, but my buddy called off, so I went solo into opening day at south Sequoia National Park 1979. 30-06. What is a DLP killing? I don't carry . 357 S&W Magnum. 45 ACP with only 4. I chose to use a Taurus revolver in . The Ruger 77/357 weighs just 5. #22 · Aug 8, 2012. Owners rarely part with them. 44 Magnum is recommended to ensure quick and humane kills. All this being said, the only deer I've ever lost with a handgun was with a 44mag. 357 is categorically less powerful in terms of available foot-pounds and bullet mass. 357 would need about 33% more energy to be on par with the best of the . 357 Magnum vs . 357 with the appropriate hard cast bullet. Looking for advice from those who have owned or handled one, mostly my concern is feel and handling. They're a ton of fun to shoot but not enough oomph. Aug 10, 2012 · Bob K. Liberalism is a cancer Support Christian Family Values Jul 6, 2006 #6 C Craig Knight In 2018 I DLP'ed a black bear boar with a GP-100 . 44 Mag at a distance of around 100 yards, but they do perform quite similar at the 50 yards mark. That being said, I'd go with the heaviest bullet you can get. 44 Magnum revolver at hand every time I head to the shooting range or hunting field – for good reason too. 44 Mag can be a little slower as it deals with heavier bullets, which results in heavy recoil. 44 Magnum with 240 grain Winchester solid point bullets. Jan 02, 2021 · The . In any case, if you don't own a . May 18, 2021 · Marlin’s big . A Smith & Wesson Model 29, in . 357 mag /38spc. 357 will always be easier to shoot and generally more accurate. If you want a faster velocity, you always have the option to choose smaller and lighter bullets. 44 mag , . 1,191 Posts. At the muzzle, our most energetic . When hunting black bear, use a rifle with good sights and a scope. Ballistics Comparison Nov 02, 2019 · The . 44 is FAR more energetic than the . Their high velocities are attributed to their bullet weights. Aug 10, 2012 · In any case, if you don't own a . Feb 05, 2015 · It is definately more pronounced with the 44mag than the 357mag. 45 Colt +P loads are literally . 357 Mag/. 44 Special. 357 Magnum were used together to stop a bear. 45 Colt. Sep 13, 2016 · 357 Magnum is superior to the 44 special in terms of more stopping power for self defense. In 2003 it was a bull moose with a SW 329PD (ported). com. Aug 06, 2012 · Black bear vs. 30-06 vs 308 vs 300 Win Mag Ammo. 44 Magnum 310-grain hard-cast load, and Buffalo Bore's . This was fun to Shoot enjoy!Thanks for watching. 44 Magnum is the minimum for charging bears, many others have opted for a Glock 20 in 10mm Auto and, interestingly enough, passed right by the . 444 uses the same diameter bullet (0 . Aug 02, 2017 · Since kinetic energy is equal to one-half the mass times the square of the velocity of a given projectile, the . Aug 02, 2017 · Moving up to 250 gr bullets we see a velocity of 1186 for 780 foot pounds in the . 44 Magnum or other larger cartridge. This feature alone makes the caliber available to more shooters, some who perhaps shied away due to the wrist-snap inherent in any magnum cartridge. 44 magnum has some differences when compared to 357 and 9mm as follows: 44 magnum vs. Bears, including grizzlies, have been killed with 22 long rifles. However, using a more powerful cartridge such as the . 300 H&H Magnum Ammo -. Joined: Nov 2005 Today we take some revolvers out for fun. 38 Special! Like all Bond Arms Derringer barrels, this 6 inch barrel . 357 Magnum, I used a Ruger GP100. It is my turn to get into the stand and self film my bear hunt. With Black Bears, the noise of the shot might scare him away. get a . 99 Brownells. 44 Magnum currently produce four loadings for use in both handguns and rifles. At that point, I knew that the . 920 foot pounds with a screaming 1,691 fps. 357 typically gets loaded with lighter rounds, as it is a smaller diameter. 357 Magnum than a . Oct 20, 2018 · . It was a campsite that was torn apart and it seemed the humans made a hasty retreat. So, what’s the takeaway? There are two, it seems. Oct 10, 2007 · She weighed in at 375 lbs and wasn't considered an extremely large bear. 357 MA $ 444. 357 mag with 200g hardcast at 1250fps or more, depending on barrel length. So to sum up, the difference between . Nov 02, 2019 · The . Unlike many other cartridges, the . Three of the most practical bear back-up handgun cartridges available are: (from left) Buffalo Bore's 10mm Auto 220-grain hard-cast load, Garrett's . 44 Magnum is actually three cartridges. Ballistics Comparison Jun 03, 2019 · 8. 023" of bullet diameter, about 10 grains of bullet weight (<10% gap), almost 400 fps of initial velocity (~40% gap. 44 special on the other hand will give you 1032 for 591 foot pounds. 357 revolvers were used to defend against bears. 44 down to 145 grs. The 44 Mag’s wider case accordingly seats a broader and heavier bullet – two factors that contribute heavily to the greater damage it can inflict. 41 Magnum, . As you might imagine, that was the end of Mr. 454 Casull were each used once — the bears died in each. 357 magnum vs 44 magnum for black bear

gijj ltuos drq gma rt pdi feknc ww mnvvc kb